In Seth v K-Bro Linen Systems Inc., 2026 ABKB 790 (Akgungor, J), the Alberta Court of King’s Bench found that an employer’s decision to place an employee on unpaid medical leave did not constitute constructive dismissal in the circumstances.
This case is important because unpaid leaves often are considered constructive dismissals, and this case provides some guidance as to when that may not be the case.
Facts
The following were the pertinent facts summarized by the ABKB:
- The plaintiff employee Mr. Seth was employed by K-Bro linen Systems for over 40 years
- The employer was in the commercial linen and laundry business
- The employee’s role at the end was that of Senior Production Manager, indirectly responsible for supervising approximately 140 employees and directly responsible for supervising four supervisors and one Production Manager
- The employee suffered a back injury at home
- The employee provided a medical note and was allowed to work from home for several months. He was given access to view cameras on the production floor from home
- After a few months working from home, he had a discussion with the employer. He alleged he was told his employment was being terminated for not being able to work, while the employer’s evidence was that he was told he was being placed on unpaid medical leave until he could return to work at the shop, and should apply for long term disability (LTD) benefits
- The employer’s position was that Mr. Seth’s job duties required him to be present at the shop so he could supervise the shop floor and give direction as situations arose. The employer’s evidence was that the initial paid time from home was temporary, and that he was not able to provide the same level of assistance from home and his absence caused a substantial increase in workload for other supervisors and managers
- The employee’s position was that his job duties were mostly administrative and did not require his physical presence at the shop to complete
- There did not appear to be any dispute that the employee was not medically able to work in person at the plant at any relevant point after the injury
Analysis / Conclusion
The ABKB found that the employee had not been outright terminated as he had alleged, but found the employer had put him on unpaid leave.
Constructive Dismissal / Accommodation
The Court summarized the law of constrictive dismissal and noted that unpaid leave can constitute constructive dismissal depending on the circumstances.
The Court noted that although this was not a human rights claim for failure to accommodate per se, it would consider the human rights aspect, because:
[140] […] the steps taken by K-Bro in terms of providing duties, or not providing duties, to Mr. Seth from the perspective of constructive dismissal, intersect with the duty to accommodate and I will consider duty to accommodate principles in that light.
The Court disagreed with the employee’s position that his role was exclusively administrative, finding that his “core function as the Senior Production Manager was to oversee and ensure the efficiency of the production floor” and this included “hands on” work which included making quick decisions about what was happening in front of him.
Accordingly, the Court agreed with the employer that regular and daily presence on the production floor was a crucial part of Mr. Seth’s role.
The Court found that the “work from home” arrangement was a temporary accommodation and accepted the employer’s evidence that he was not able to provide as much value from home and his absence caused an increase in the workload of others.
The Court found that in this case, the employer’s choice to put Mr. Seth on an unpaid medical leave was not a failure to accommodate and did not amount to constructive dismissal:
[159] While an employer has a duty to provide reasonable accommodation, reasonable accommodation does not require employers to change working conditions in a fundamental way: Syndicat des employes de techniques professionelles & de bureau d’Hydro-Quebec, 2008 SCC 43 at para 16. In my view, requiring an employer to provide accommodation by allowing an employee to perform only incidental administrative tasks rather than the essential duties of their role would amount to changing working conditions in a fundamental way.
[…]
[173] Faced with a seemingly moving target in terms of any expected return to work date and no clear prognosis and considering the frailties of the work from home arrangement, it was both reasonable and justified, in my view, to place Mr. Seth on a medical leave at this point. The fact that the medical leave was unpaid does mean it was unreasonable. Absent a contractual or statutory obligation or a policy of the employer (none of which are present here), there is no freestanding obligation on an employer to pay an employee who is on medical leave and not performing work as a result. In the present case, K-Bro did not provide paid sick leave or short-term disability.
Since there was no outright dismissal or constructive dismissal, the plaintiff’s claim was dismissed in its entirety.
My Take
This case provides helpful guidance on some relatively technical legal issues surrounding accommodation and constructive dismissal in the context of an unpaid leave of absence.
This case is also part of a very limited body of Alberta caselaw where a civil court (King’s Bench in this case) has considered human rights arguments in its assessment. This is normally reserved for the Alberta Human Rights Tribunal, but a few cases have found that human rights aspects sometimes intersect with other civil claims such that it is appropriate to consider them together in civil court.
This case is tragic in some ways, without a doubt. However, given the findings of fact of what actually happened, the result is not surprising to me. If the employer had terminated his employment, or he had made accommodation requests involving a physical return to work that were denied, it likely would have turned out differently. The difficulty in this case is that he was not able to carry out some of his core duties, and:
- An employer is not generally required to create a new position for accommodation
- An employer is not generally required to pay someone for a period they are not able to carry out their work
Bow River Law provides these regular legal blog articles for the purposes of legal news, education and research for the public and the legal profession. These articles should be considered general information and not legal advice. If you have a legal problem, you should speak to a lawyer directly.
This blog post is an original work of Bow River Law LLP. The original publish of this article is on Bow River Law’s website blog.




