In D’Aoust v Foisy Law, 2026 AHRC 125, the Alberta Human Rights Tribunal awarded a complainant $30,000 in general damages and over 8 months’ lost wages for discrimination on the basis of disability and gender (maternity).
This case is important because of what was considered an adverse impact and when the lost wages portion of damages began to accrue.
Legal counsel for the successful complainant was BRL employment and human rights lawyer Michael Hernandez.
Facts
The following were the pertinent facts summarized by the AHRT:
- The complainant employee started working for the respondent law firm as an articling student in 2020
- During her articles, she was in a motor vehicle accident and suffered a traumatic brain injury
- She received some accommodations, including time for treatment and appointments, and sometimes working from home
- She became an associate lawyer for the employer in September, 2021
- She went on maternity leave on July 1, 2022. She continued doing a small amount of work on files while on leave
- Her remote access was restricted when she went on leave. The employer’s explanation was that this was because she did not require access while on leave and there was a chance she would not return
- On October 25, 2022, while she was still on maternity leave, the complainant employee attended at the employer’s office. By this time, the employer was moving towards ending her employment. During this meeting, the employer referenced the employee’s traumatic brain injury and suggested government employment would be a more suitable alternative for her. The employer communicated to her that she would not have long term employment at the firm after returning from maternity leave. She understood that her employment was ending
- The employer had paid her ALIA insurance levies in full while she was employed, but while on maternity leave the employee was advised a levy was outstanding and she paid it
- On February 6, 2023, the employer wrote to the complainant asking when she intended to return from maternity leave. On March 2, 2023, the complainant responded that she had been informed on October 25 that her employment would be terminated when she returned from maternity leave
- The employer’s response did not state that the complainant’s recollection of the October 25 meeting was incorrect. Instead, it stated that they needed to know when the maternity leave ended so they would not “mess up any of [her] current coverage” and that once the date was confirmed the employer would “draft all of the required documents”
- The complainant filed an Alberta human rights complaint, alleging discrimination on the basis of place of origin (language skills), gender (maternity leave) and disability, seeking general damages for pain and suffering plus wage loss from October 25, 2023 onwards
- The respondent’s defense did not include an argument that the complainant was unable to meet a Bona Fide Occupational Requirement.
Analysis / Conclusion
The AHRT noted the settled test for discrimination: (1) protected characteristic; (2) adverse impact; (3) protected characteristic a factor in adverse impact. The AHRT also noted that the protected characteristic need not be the only factor in the adverse impact, and that discriminatory intent is not required.
The AHRT noted that perceived English language difficulty was not a separately enumerated ground of discrimination under the AHRA, and declined to decide whether it should be included under “place of origin” in this case because it was not necessary to determine the case on the other protected grounds she did establish, being disability and gender (maternity).
The AHRT noted that the adverse impact was “the respondent’s decision to terminate employment”.
The AHRT noted that disability was a factor in that decision to terminate because her speed on files had been discussed after the brain injury and it was referenced as a reason not to retain her as an employee.
The AHRT found that gender (maternity) was also a factor in the decision to terminate her employment. Some of the main reasons were: she had not been told prior to maternity leave of a potential termination of employment; the employer only started considering this once she was on maternity leave; and, the employer’s evidence was that its plan was to permit her to return because it was legally required to do so, but not to restore the employment relationship that existed before the leave. The AHRT noted, “She would return without her own files, work principally in a research or support capacity, and remain at the job only during working notice before the employment relationship ended.”
The AHRT also noted the following principle:
[126] […] an employer cannot use a protected leave as an opportunity to leave the employee in a worse position because she took the leave […]
The employer argued the complainant’s employment had not been terminated, but she failed to provide notice of returning from maternity leave. The AHRT found it was unnecessary to determine if she had been dismissed on October 25 or some later date, because the October 25 decision was an adverse employment decision and the evidence supported that both parties understood the employment relationship had changed by March 2.
The AHRT assessed general damages for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect at $30,000. Some of the factors noted were:
- The complainant had a disability the employer was well aware of
- The complainant was on maternity leave with an infant daughter and recovering from childbirth at the time of the October 25 adverse impact. Maternity leave is intended to permit a person to care for their child with some security that they have employment to return to. She described losing enjoyment with her daughter because of preoccupation with her financial future
- The complainant felt betrayed that her injury was raised in connection with future employment
For lost wages, the AHRT assessed the complainant’s wage losses from October 25 to July, at which point she had obtained alternative employment.
The AHRT acknowledged that a significant portion of this period occurred when she was on maternity leave and would not normally have received a salary. However, the AHRT still awarded it, noting as follows:
[172] The respondent cannot, however, obtain the benefit of treating D’Aoust’s protected leave as a period of unpaid working notice. I note that this was not a period where D’Aoust was entirely inactive. She continued her professional responsibilities to the courts and her clients.
My Take
This case is fairly unique for two reasons:
- The adverse impact first occurred on October 25, when it became clear that the complainant’s long-term employment prospects with the respondent were ending. It was not found she was dismissed on that day, but the loss of long term employment prospects was itself an adverse impact
- The complainant’s wage losses began on October 25 as well, while she was on maternity leave. Most prior cases would fix the date of those losses at the date she was set to return to work
I have personally seen many instances of employers terminating in the middle of a maternity leave. While generally this is inadvisable, there are some quirks in the typical calculation of damages that explains why this is sometimes done. D’Aoust makes it harder for employers to take that approach.
Bow River Law provides these regular legal blog articles for the purposes of legal news, education and research for the public and the legal profession. These articles should be considered general information and not legal advice. If you have a legal problem, you should speak to a lawyer directly.
This blog post is an original work of Bow River Law LLP. The original publish of this article is on Bow River Law’s website blog.



