AHRT Finds Offer Not “Fair and Reasonable” And Refuses to Dismiss Complaint

Employee-Sued-by-Employer-in-Calgary

In Complainant v Edmonton Police Service, 2026 AHRC 126, an employer offered settlement of $15,000 plus an accommodated work transfer.  The Tribunal found this was not a “fair and reasonable” settlement offer, and declined to dismiss the complaint.

This case is important because: (1) the Tribunal quite often dismisses complaints for failure to accept settlement offers, but did not in this case, and (2) the reasoning in this case contains more detailed analysis of the offer terms than is typical of the Tribunal.

Facts

The following were the pertinent facts summarized by the AHRT:

  • The complainant was employed by the Edmonton Police Service
  • The complainant was denied a training opportunity
  • The complainant filed a human rights complaint against his employer related to alleged discrimination (disability) in employment practices under section 7 of the Alberta Human Rights Act
  • After filing the initial complaint, the complainant alleged he had been retaliated against, and filed several more complaints
  • The employer made an offer to settle the human rights complaints which consisted of $15,000 and an accommodated work transfer on a number of terms and conditions, including:
    • He would be placed in a temporary modified duties role for a trial period
    • He would be placed in a permanent accommodated position “when one arises”
    • The applicable modified duties would at all times be contingent on specific conditions, including approval by WCB
  • The complainant rejected the offer
  • The employer brought an application to have the complaints dismissed for failure to accept a “fair and reasonable” settlement offer

Analysis / Conclusion

The AHRT noted that it was required to consider the “totality of the offer of settlement” to determine if it was reasonable in the circumstances, and confirmed that the burden (onus) was on the employer to prove this.

The AHRT first considered the $15,000 component of the offer:

  • The AHRT conducted some limited weighing of the strength of the complaints and found there was enough evidence that the complaints could be established
  • The AHRT determined that if the complaints were successful, they would likely result in damages exceeding $15,000
  • The AHRT determined that the $15,000 component was not “fair and reasonable”

The AHRT then considered the offer of an accommodated work transfer.  The AHRT found that the conditions specified appeared to be restrictive, and that if the complaint were successful it was “doubtful that the Tribunal would order that the complainant’s disability be accommodated on the terms and conditions stipulated in the respondent’s offer of employment”.

In considering the whole offer together, the Tribunal found it was not “fair and reasonable” and declined to dismiss the human rights complaints.

 

My Take

To me, the most interesting point raised by the Tribunal in its analysis of reasonableness was that if the complaint were successful it is unlikely the Tribunal would order accommodations on the terms and conditions the employer had stipulated.

I think this analysis makes sense.

However, I would point out that it looks like a potential directional change on how AHRT handles these applications.  Consider, for instance, that the AHRT regularly dismisses complaints without any (or scant) analysis on the terms of release proposed by the employer.

If all the terms of settlement offer matter, surely the terms of release matter.  If the employer must prove the terms of accommodation are reasonable, one would think they must also prove that the terms of a proposed release are reasonable too.

We’ll have to wait patiently to find out of this case represents a shift or not.

Joel Fairbrother is an employment lawyer and litigator.

Bow River Law provides these regular legal blog articles for the purposes of legal news, education and research for the public and the legal profession.  These articles should be considered general information and not legal advice.  If you have a legal problem, you should speak to a lawyer directly.

This blog post is an original work of Bow River Law LLP.  The original publish of this article is on Bow River Law’s website blog.